Sisterly Love

Staff Writer
Staff Writer

Success Stories

January 1st, 2007

Sisterly Love

2

When I (Coleen) first joined Catholic Match in 2004, one of my

first matches was Mike. After reading his profile and learning he loves

sports, camping and had been in the army for fifteen years, I was

certain he was the perfect match - for my sister.  I even showed

his profile to her and encouraged her to join CM so that she could

contact him.

From June of 2004 to September 2005, Mike was

periodically matched with me. Each time I would say to my sister,

"Cath, take a look at this guy. You both seem to have so much in

common."  I even received an email from Mike right after I joined

in June 2004. Of course, I tried to get my sister to respond, but she

was not ready.  I did not want to ignore him, and so I sent off a

quick reply telling him that I was going out of town (we were about to

go out west for four weeks).  I wrote that I would be back in

early August. If he were still interested then, he could email me.

I

did not receive a reply for over a year.  Why didn't I take the

next step and email him upon my return?  Well, I am a bit of an

"old-fashioned" kind of woman. Some might even say when it comes to the

dating dance, I am a traditionalist. 

I believe the man

makes not only makes the first move, but he leads.  So, when I did

not hear from Mike, I figured he was not interested.  For the next

year, I would be repeatedly matched with Mike and repeatedly I would

encourage my sister to join CM and make contact with him. (Lucky for

me, she did not take me up on any of my repeated suggestions). 

Finally, in September 2005, a year and a few months after the first

message, I received a second email from Mike.

When I think

back to the day Mike emailed me for the second time, I was about to

give up on CM. I really did not want to spend the money, as I was not

seeing much of a result. Mike later told me that his membership had

actually expired (and he did not have plans to renew either) when I

emailed him back.  He decided to go on a month to month for a

while.  After the first email, Mike asked to call but, I put the

brakes on and said, "Let's get to know each other first." 

Finally,

after six weeks of emails, I gave the green light to call. Our first

conversation was so easy, and comfortable - it was like coming home. We

talked for over 2 1/2 hours about everything from faith, family, career

goals, hopes, etc. As our relationship unfolded, it became clear that

God had a plan for us. From Mike's belief that he might be called to

Holy Orders through the diaconate program combined with the fact that

my father was ordained a deacon in 1999 to strange coincidences such as

his name. His name is Michael Patrick and he is the oldest son- I have

a brother named Mike (he's the oldest, too) and a brother

Patrick.  We found out that we both were attending the same church

and only lived 10 miles from each other. Most importantly, we both

shared a strong catholic faith, which has been bedrock for each of

us. 


Originally, I was going to wait a long time to

introduce Mike to my sons. Mike left the timing entirely up to me,

knowing that I was just being protective of them. I did not want them

to become attached to someone who would not be in their life in six

months. However, about three months after our first email, it was

obvious our relationship had a future. I did not like keeping it a

secret.

Finally, during the 2005 holiday season, I decided

the time was right and I put aside my concerns. I would learn that I

had nothing to fear. In fact, watching Mike with my two sons has

revealed much about the kind of man Mike is as well as confirming that

he was a man I wanted my sons to emulate. There is an old saying that

the "way to a man's heart is through his stomach."  Well, I

believe "to see the true depth of a man's heart look for his ability to

love and nurture someone else's child unconditionally.  Mike's

willingness to accept and love my sons has been a testament to how

much love he is capable of giving to others. He has willingly nurtured

and loved both my sons since the moment he met them and they have

welcomed him into their lives as well. What more could I ask? Well...


Flash forward to one year later - November 2006.  Mike and I have

been together for a year. We are sitting at a table at IL Bellagio

where we first met almost one year ago. We sat at a table by the

fountain. It is a warm night in South Florida. Mike turns to me, gets

down on one knee, and says,"Coleen, my Irish rose, will you marry me?

Will you be my wife?"  He opens a small, red heart-shaped box to

revealing an engagement ring. Without hesitation, I joyfully answered,

"Yes." From almost giving up on CM to encouraging my sister to contact

Mike to misperceptions, there were so many potential detours to the two

of us getting together and against all those detours, we still found

each other.  We are planning on a wedding for June 2007.



2

— This article has been read 132 times

Find Your Forever

CatholicMatch is the largest and most trusted
Catholic dating site in the world.

Get Started for Free!
Continue Reading
CatholicMatch
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Browse Catholic Singles

St. Raphael, patron of Catholic singles - Pray for us!

St. Raphael, patron of Catholic singles - Pray for us!

CatholicMatch, Emotigram, Find Your Forever, Grow in Faith - Fall in Love, and Faith Focused Dating are registered trademarks and/or trademarks of CatholicMatch, LLC

© Copyright 2025